Comments on: Hacking a research project http://discontents.com.au/hacking-a-research-project/ working for the triumph of content over form, ideas over control, people over systems Fri, 03 Nov 2017 05:29:17 +0000 hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=4.8.17 By: Tim Sherratt (@wragge) http://discontents.com.au/hacking-a-research-project/#comment-466118 Wed, 30 Aug 2017 06:47:07 +0000 http://discontents.com.au/?p=878#comment-466118 When @baibi & I starting working on @invisibleaus we always said we needed to be patient & opportunistic: https://t.co/S5qNCl4cTm

]]>
By: discontents - An infrastructure wishlist http://discontents.com.au/hacking-a-research-project/#comment-91 Tue, 08 Nov 2011 11:46:10 +0000 http://discontents.com.au/?p=878#comment-91 […] multi-institutional partnerships. It just doesn’t seem like a great model for innovation. As I’ve previously argued, I’d like to see something more like the funding schemes offered by the NEH Office for […]

]]>
By: discontents - Inside the big tent http://discontents.com.au/hacking-a-research-project/#comment-90 Wed, 22 Dec 2010 13:44:07 +0000 http://discontents.com.au/?p=878#comment-90 […] for the Digital Humanities dispensing start-up grants for innovative digital projects. I want a new research funding system. I want THATCamps every other […]

]]>
By: Len Smith http://discontents.com.au/hacking-a-research-project/#comment-89 Mon, 20 Sep 2010 02:14:37 +0000 http://discontents.com.au/?p=878#comment-89 Great project. Our project tracing Tasmanian convicts from their convictions in Britain and Ireland to their descendants’ experience in the First Australian Infantry Force has faced many of the technical and resourcing issues you describe. We have had some success obtaining ARC funding for this and an earlier project to reconstruct the Victorian Koori population, and have created rich prosopographical databases which are potentially permanent research resources. But almost by definition the ARC does not provide funds for sustainable databases. We are already facing the need to migrate the Koori data to a more up-to-date repository. As others have commented, there are several issue here: the need to recognise the creation and maintenance of sustainable databases as a central part of the research process (which is implicit in ANDS); the need for some sort of technical infrastructure to support it; and (especially) the need to harness the creativity of the open source community in its development. The challenge is to find a way of bringing together the necessarily bureaucratic infrastructure component with the creative hacker component.

]]>
By: discontents - Embedded archives http://discontents.com.au/hacking-a-research-project/#comment-88 Sun, 27 Jun 2010 12:00:20 +0000 http://discontents.com.au/?p=878#comment-88 […] of you may have noticed that my Hacking a research project post featured a file from the National Archives of Australia embedded as a Cooliris widget. Huh? To […]

]]>
By: asa letourneau http://discontents.com.au/hacking-a-research-project/#comment-87 Wed, 23 Jun 2010 11:50:00 +0000 http://discontents.com.au/?p=878#comment-87 Would love to lend my support to this and would be especially interested in discussing opportunities for collaboration with PROV, (though I have no idea how this would play out). From working with PROV over the last 5 years I am aware of some of the cultural sensitiivity issues surrounding projects such as the KIN database, and a an exhibition dealing with Chinese prisoners in Victoria in the 19th century. Consultation, as far as is reasonably practicable, with the relevant communities would to be an obvious source of collaborative power. To re-interpret and re-possess the past in order to accurately re-present what was actually being done to these communtities is crucial to a shared and honest understanding. As for the funding? That never stood in the way of a great idea…let’s make it happen!

]]>
By: dogpossum http://discontents.com.au/hacking-a-research-project/#comment-86 Mon, 21 Jun 2010 03:32:27 +0000 http://discontents.com.au/?p=878#comment-86 This is such an interesting topic. But I do think the issue of privacy – or the right to say how and when and why your image/information is used – is absolutely central to this issue. Even if the subject has passed away, these issues still apply. There are ongoing discussions on this topic in regards to the use of materials referencing indigenous Australians, and bodies like AIATSIS can offer useful advice.
There’s a conference coming up very soon which will have attendees who can advise: http://www.aiatsis.gov.au/research/symposia/Digi10.html

Sometimes it’s more important to be able to restrict the use of your family’s image/information than to communicate it. This has come up in regards to Yuendumu in quite interesting ways http://www.warlpiri.com.au/visitors.htm has a fascinating document about how access to Yuendumu as a physical place is related to land rights, to civil liberty and to the documentation of the lives of disempowered or marginalised people.

]]>
By: Kate http://discontents.com.au/hacking-a-research-project/#comment-85 Mon, 21 Jun 2010 02:02:24 +0000 http://discontents.com.au/?p=878#comment-85 Thanks to Chris and Shane for their comments about the privacy issue. Here are some thoughts connected to my own research into the history of Anglo-Chinese Australian families.

I’ve been working with the White Australia Policy/Immigration Restriction Act records for more than ten years and it has grown to be something of an obsession. My passion for them, and for what they can tell us, comes precisely because they contain such rich information about real people.

Much of the history of the Chinese in Australia has been written from sources such as government reports, parliamentary debates and major urban newspapers, and unfortunately many of the biases of these sources have been carried through into later descriptions of the life of 19th and early 20th century Chinese Australians. My particular interest is in women, sex and the family (especially interracial families), an area in which there are stereotypes aplenty.

What I sought to do in my doctoral research was to get past the stereotypes, and the way I saw to do this was to find out all I could about real people. I manually did the kind of data matching that could now potentially be done in the online world, working from sources that gave me a bit of information here and a bit of information there, to build up something of a picture of their lives. The Immigration Restriction Act records played a big part in this, particularly in putting faces to the names, and in giving a voice to my subjects themselves.

The other thing I chose to do was to seek contact with the descendants of the individuals and families that I encountered in the archives. I put ads in newspapers, wrote to family history societies, posted to online genealogy forums and co-founded a Chinese family history group. When my thesis was completed, I made it accessible online through the Australian Digital Theses program. I did not disguise the identities of the people I wrote about either, which means that I continue to receive email from people researching their families who’ve come across my work through a simple Google search.

Because of the racism encountered by many Chinese and mixed race families, the Chinese part of family stories have often been hidden, and most of those people who contact me are just embarking on a process of discovery. Finding that the National Archives holds these records, with photographs, physical descriptions, personal and family details, the names of ancestral homes in China, signatures and sometimes letters written by family members is a revelation. In all my contact with descendants over more than a decade, I can think of no more than two instances where the families had concerns about the records being available publicly.

Making these connections between the archive, the historian and the family/community can have benefits for all of us. Every time I make contact with another family I am reminded how the archive, however rich, really only tells one part of the story of someone’s life. Getting to hear about people from the family’s perspective is a real privilege.

I tend to think therefore that there is a greater good being served by making these records, and the people in them, more visible – through better archival description (to enable name-based keyword searching, for instance), through digitisation and through projects like the one Tim and I are embarking on. It helps people to reconnect with their own pasts, and it also gives the rest of us a better understanding of how the White Australian Policy (which was ostensibly designed to limit non-white migration) affected the lives of people who were in fact Australians too.

]]>
By: Penny http://discontents.com.au/hacking-a-research-project/#comment-84 Sun, 20 Jun 2010 18:42:13 +0000 http://discontents.com.au/?p=878#comment-84 In the dissertation I mapped the alumnae and made family charts for them, but that was before any online options–no search engines, no genealogy forums. So the blogged reboot of the project will have much richer data for mapping and family relationships.

I haven’t taken the project “out” into the family history online world yet–I will soon, when I have about 50 names done–but I’ve had some inquiries and tips already. A small house museum in the South asked if the family who owned the house sent any daughters to the school; and some tipped me to a tombstone in Gibraltar related to one of the students’ stories.

]]>
By: Andy McGregor http://discontents.com.au/hacking-a-research-project/#comment-83 Sun, 20 Jun 2010 16:03:39 +0000 http://discontents.com.au/?p=878#comment-83 If you want to see the results of the latest round of JISC rapid innovation funding, we published a newspaper rounding up some of the most successful projects. You can see a digital version here: http://ie-repository.jisc.ac.uk/450/ the paper version contains a map of all the projects we funded, here is a hyperlinked version: http://bit.ly/bfWyML

]]>